Coverage dated April 19, 2023 to April 23, 2023

Twitter Blue marks show up for dead celebrities, sowing confusion

Headline from KRQE Albuquerque, on the newest of 2 developments

Explanations on each page said the accounts were “verified because they are subscribed to Twitter Blue and verified their phone number.”

KRQE Albuquerque's own description from its feed. We collect headlines and these descriptions, not full articles; read the original reporting below.

Developments in this update

2 dated developments, oldest first, newest marked. Each is named by one outlet's own headline; open its reports to see every outlet that covered it.

  1. Celebrities reject Twitter's blue check after mysterious return

    Headline from KREM Spokane ·

  2. Newest

    Twitter Blue marks show up for dead celebrities, sowing confusion

    Headline from KRQE Albuquerque ·

Reports & sources

58 articles, oldest first.

  1. Insider

    Twitter users including Justin Bieber, Bill Gates, and Kim Kardashian are seeing their blue checkmarks disappear as Elon Musk charges $8 a month for verified accounts (opens Insider)

    Published

    Insider's feed description

    Figures including Lady Gaga, Selena Gomez, Kim Kardashian, and Kylie Jenner appeared to lose their legacy Twitter verification Thursday.

  2. CNN

    Elon Musk's Twitter begins purge of blue check marks (opens CNN)

    Published

    CNN's feed description

    Elon Musk's Twitter on Thursday began a purge of blue verification checkmarks from users who have not signed up for its subscription service, with the checks disappearing from the accounts of journalists, academics and some celebrities.

  3. Bloomberg

    Twitter’s Legacy Blue Checks Are Gone, Fulfilling Musk’s Promise (opens Bloomberg)

    Published

    Bloomberg's feed description

    Twitter’s legacy blue checkmarks are officially gone — the conclusion of a promise made weeks ago by new owner Elon Musk to remove the icon that was once reserved for public figures in favor of a new paid verification program that anyone can sign up for.

  4. Wall Street Journal

    Twitter Begins Removing Legacy Check Marks (opens Wall Street Journal)

    Published

    Wall Street Journal's feed description

    Celebrities appeared to lose their blue check marks as the social-media platform moves in favor of paid subscriptions.

  5. Deadline

    Twitter Starts Long-Planned Removal Of Blue Check Marks; Purge Affects Journalists, Brands, Entertainers And Even Pope Francis (opens Deadline)

    Published

    Deadline's feed description

    Twitter has begun a wide-scale process of removing the blue check marks from verified account holders, a large swath of the platform’s most high-profile users including journalists, celebriti…

  6. Variety

    Elon Musk Removes Twitter Legacy Blue Check Marks (opens Variety)

    Published

    Variety's feed description

    Elon Musk's Twitter started purging legacy blue check-marks from many user accounts, including Beyoncé, Lady Gaga, Kim Kardashian and Oprah.

  7. The Guardian

    ‘Legacy blue checks’ disappear from Twitter as Musk’s changes take effect (opens The Guardian)

    Published

    The Guardian's feed description

    Checkmark denoted accounts verified for authenticity, which can now be bought for an $8 a month subscription called Twitter Blue

  8. CNET

    Twitter Purges Legacy Blue Check Marks (opens CNET)

    Published

    CNET's feed description

    If you want to be verified, you'll have to pay for Twitter Blue. Here's how to subscribe.

  9. Digital Trends

    Twitter ditches legacy check mark and it's already confusing (opens Digital Trends)

    Published

    Digital Trends's feed description

    Twitter has started removing the blue check marks from accounts that have not signed up to its Blue subscription service, and it's already confusing.

  10. Foxla

    Twitter starts removing blue check marks from users who don’t pay (opens Foxla)

    Published

    Foxla's feed description

    Twitter will require users to pay a monthly fee to keep the blue check mark. The social media giant had about 300,000 verified users under the original blue check system — many of them journalists, athletes, and public figures.

  11. Bowling Green Daily News

    Twitter begins removing blue checks from users who don't pay (opens Bowling Green Daily News)

    Published

    Bowling Green Daily News's feed description

    This time it’s for real. Many of Twitter’s high-profile users are have lost the blue check marks that helped verify their identity and distinguish them from impostors on the Elon

  12. KVUE

    Twitter's blue check mark removal hits celebrities and even the pope (opens KVUE)

    Published

    KVUE's feed description

    Blue check marks were originally used on Twitter to verify identities and distinguish real accounts from impostors. Now it'll mean someone is paying a monthly fee.

  13. New York Post

    Celebrities losing blue checks as Twitter begins enforcing payment (opens New York Post)

    Published

    New York Post's feed description

    High-profile users who lost their blue checks Thursday included Beyoncé, Pope Francis, Oprah Winfrey and former President Donald Trump.

  14. The Guardian

    With Twitter’s legacy blue checks gone, here’s how to see if celebrities and other users are real (opens The Guardian)

    Published

    The Guardian's feed description

    Users from the Pope to former US president Donald Trump had their blue checks removed, while Elon Musk paid costs for some celebrities

  15. Forbes

    Twitter Restores Blue Check Marks For Many High-Profile Accounts—But Some Celebrities Don’t Want Them (opens Forbes)

    Published

    Forbes's feed description

    Those making it clear they do not subscribe to Twitter Blue include Chrissy Teigen and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

  16. Engadget

    Twitter adds blue checks to accounts of dead celebrities (opens Engadget)

    Published

    Engadget's feed description

    Twitter has begun handing out blue ticks to celebrity users and accounts with more than one million followers..

  17. Washington Times

    Confusion as Musk’s Twitter yanks blue checks from agencies (opens Washington Times)

    Published

    Washington Times's feed description

    When the Elon Musk-owned platform started stripping blue verification check marks this week from accounts that don’t pay a monthly fee, it left public agencies and other organizations around the world scrambling to figure out a way to be trusted.

  18. Fortune

    Twitter blue checks for dead celebrities adds to confusion over Elon Musk’s changes (opens Fortune)

    Published

    Fortune's feed description

    The Twitter accounts of Kobe Bryant and Anthony Bourdain sporting blue check marks left many users perplexed.

  19. Insider

    Twitter is adding verified check marks to the accounts of dead celebrities, making them look like paid Twitter Blue subscribers (opens Insider)

    Published

    Insider's feed description

    Kobe Bryant, Anthony Bourdain, and Chadwick Boseman were among the celebrities the app says bought a subscription and verified their phone number.

  20. Bloomberg

    Twitter Blue Ticks for Dead Celebrities Add to Verification Confusion (opens Bloomberg)

    Published

    Bloomberg's feed description

    Twitter Inc. users already having to navigate a flurry of fake accounts after the removal of legacy blue ticks are noticing more inconsistencies: personalities who have been dead for years supposedly holding paid verification accounts.

  21. The Boston Globe

    Twitter blue checks for dead celebrities add to verification confusion (opens The Boston Globe)

    Published

    The Boston Globe's feed description

    Twitter Inc. users already having to navigate a flurry of fake accounts after the removal of legacy blue ticks are noticing more inconsistencies: personalities who have been dead for years supposedly holding paid verification accounts.

  22. KRQE Albuquerque

    Twitter Blue marks show up for dead celebrities, sowing confusion (opens KRQE Albuquerque)

    Published

    KRQE Albuquerque's feed description

    Explanations on each page said the accounts were “verified because they are subscribed to Twitter Blue and verified their phone number.”

  23. KREM Spokane

    Celebrities reject Twitter's blue check after mysterious return (opens KREM Spokane)

    Published

    KREM Spokane's feed description

    Twitter removed the blue marks last week from "legacy" accounts that don’t pay a monthly fee.

  24. CNN

    How Elon Musk transformed Twitter's blue check from status symbol into a badge of shame (opens CNN)

    Published

    CNN's feed description

    Days after Elon Musk's Twitter purged blue check marks from VIP users and prominent organizations, the checks reappeared on the accounts of a number of high-profile figures, many of whom promptly stressed they did not ask for or did not want the new verification badge.

  25. Triblive

    Twitter verification reappears, but some disavow Musk’s mark (opens Triblive)

    Published

    Triblive's feed description

    SAN FRANCISCO — Celebrities and other high-profile Twitter users are once again being verified by the social media platform and they don’t know why the blue check marks reappeared — nor do they seem too happy about it. Twitter removed the blue marks last week from accounts that don’t pay

Showing the first 25 of 32 headlines. ·

Identical headlines usually mean shared wire copy. They are counted as separate articles but are not independent confirmation.

Twitter Blue marks show up for dead celebrities, sowing confusion | Since Then