Coverage dated May 11, 2025 to May 15, 2025

Supreme Court justices seem divided in birthright citizenship arguments

Headline from Delaware Public Media, on the newest of 3 developments

The U.S. Supreme Court seemed at least partially divided as the justices heard arguments debating how the lower courts should handle President Trump's executive order on birthright citizenship.

Delaware Public Media's own description from its feed. We collect headlines and these descriptions, not full articles; read the original reporting below.

Earlier updates in this story

Developments in this update

3 dated developments, oldest first, newest marked. Each is named by one outlet's own headline; open its reports to see every outlet that covered it.

  1. Trump’s bid to end birthright citizenship heads to the Supreme Court

    Headline from The Conversation US ·

  2. Supreme Court weighs limits on nationwide injunctions during birthright citizenship arguments

    Headline from The Hill ·

  3. Newest

    Supreme Court justices seem divided in birthright citizenship arguments

    Headline from Delaware Public Media ·

Read the reports

Reports & sources

129 articles, oldest first.

  1. The Daily Signal

    Justices to Weigh Birthright Citizenship-Related Injunctions, But Won’t Consider Underlying Issue (opens The Daily Signal)

    Published

    The Daily Signal's feed description

    The Supreme Court will hear arguments Wednesday in a case that stems from President Donald Trump’s decree on birthright citizenship.

  2. CNN

    Analysis: Overview of the Supreme Court arguments in birthright citizenship cases (opens CNN)

    Published

    CNN's feed description

    The Supreme Court will hear oral arguments on May 15 in three cases challenging an executive order President Donald Trump signed on January 20 purporting to limit who is entitled to “birthright citizenship,” i.e., who automatically becomes a US citizen if and when they are born on US soil.

  3. The Conversation US

    Trump’s bid to end birthright citizenship heads to the Supreme Court (opens The Conversation US)

    Published

    The Conversation US's feed description

    Three federal judges have struck down Trump’s executive order on birthright citizenship since he signed it in January 2025. Now, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in the case.

  4. ABC 11 Raleigh

    Supreme Court to weigh blocks on Trump's order to end birthright citizenship (opens ABC 11 Raleigh)

    Published

    ABC 11 Raleigh's feed description

    The Supreme Court will hear arguments over President Donald Trump's effort to to block his executive order on birthright citizenship.

  5. PBS NewsHour

    LISTEN LIVE: Supreme Court hears arguments on Trump’s challenge to birthright citizenship (opens PBS NewsHour)

    Published

    PBS NewsHour's feed description

    Birthright citizenship is among several issues the administration has asked the court to deal with on an emergency basis, after lower courts acted to slow Trump’s agenda.

  6. New York Post

    Why Trump’s Supreme Court challenge against birthright citizenship may not really be about birthright citizenship (opens New York Post)

    Published

    New York Post's feed description

    When the Supreme Court hears arguments Thursday over President Trump’s challenge to automatic birthright citizenship, the immigration spat could take a backseat to a more contested legal question.

  7. The Boston Globe

    Supreme Court could swiftly end Trump’s bid to strip birthright citizenship (opens The Boston Globe)

    Published

    The Boston Globe's feed description

    The justices don’t yet have to decide if the executive order is unconstitutional. They should anyway.

  8. Time

    Birthright Citizenship: Supreme Court Hears Case Thursday (opens Time)

    Published

    Time's feed description

    The Justices will hear arguments Thursday in a major case over two areas of law: birthright citizenship and nationwlde injunctions

  9. Fox News

    Supreme Court to debate Trump restrictions on birthright citizenship and enforcement of nationwide injunctions (opens Fox News)

    Published

    Fox News's feed description

    Trump's executive order on birthright citizenship faces Supreme Court scrutiny as justices face broader questions over nationwide injunctions and judicial authority.

  10. Newsweek

    Supreme Court finally wades into birthright citizenship debate (opens Newsweek)

    Published

    Newsweek's feed description

    The high court will hear arguments on one of Trump's most controversial legal theories — that being born in America doesn't automatically make you an American.

  11. Seattle Times

    WA birthright citizenship case arrives at Supreme Court (opens Seattle Times)

    Published

    Seattle Times's feed description

    The Trump administration wants the Supreme Court to limit the use of nationwide injunctions by federal judges blocking executive presidential actions.

  12. NBC News

    Birthright citizenship dispute at the Supreme Court has broad implications for Trump's agenda (opens NBC News)

    Published

    NBC News's feed description

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court could give a major boost to the Trump administration's muscular use of executive power when it hears arguments Thursday over his plan to end birthright citizenship.

  13. Washington Examiner

    Supreme Court takes up birthright citizenship at special hearing (opens Washington Examiner)

    Published

    Washington Examiner's feed description

    The case could not be more high-stakes as the Trump administration has been stymied by at least 17 nationwide injunctions between January and the end of March.

  14. Roll Call

    Supreme Court to hear oral arguments over birthright citizenship (opens Roll Call)

    Published

    Roll Call's feed description

    Justices will give a first glimpse Thursday of how they intend to handle the Trump administration’s attempt to end birthright citizenship.

  15. The Hill

    Live updates: Supreme Court hears birthright citizenship arguments (opens The Hill)

    Published

    The Hill's feed description

    The Supreme Court is hearing arguments on President Trump's birthright citizenship order Thursday, while he visits the Middle East and the House GOP hammers out his agenda. Follow for live updates.

  16. Breitbart News

    Supreme Court Hears Arguments in Case over Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order (opens Breitbart News)

    Published

    Breitbart News's feed description

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court is hearing its first set of Trump-related arguments in the second Trump presidency. The case stems from the executive order President Donald Trump issued on his first day in office that would deny citizenship to children born on U.S.

  17. ABC 7 Los Angeles

    Birthright citizenship explained as justices weigh blocks on Trump's order to end it (opens ABC 7 Los Angeles)

    Published

    ABC 7 Los Angeles's feed description

    The Supreme Court heard arguments over President Donald Trump's executive order on birthright citizenship.

  18. The New Republic

    Trump Justice Department Makes Insane Claim About Obeying Court Orders (opens The New Republic)

    Published

    The New Republic's feed description

    Donald Trump’s lawyers made the argument to the Supreme Court during a hearing on birthright citizenship.

  19. MyNorthwest

    The Latest: Supreme Court hears arguments in case over Trump’s birthright citizenship order (opens MyNorthwest)

    Published

    MyNorthwest's feed description

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court is hearing its first set of Trump-related arguments in the second Trump presidency. The case stems from the executive

  20. Talking Points Memo

    Birthright Citizenship Is Safe For Now. Nationwide Injunctions Are Not. (opens Talking Points Memo)

    Published

    Talking Points Memo's feed description

    The right-wing justices on Thursday were amenable to the Trump administration’s bid to pare back universal injunctions, a type of relief where lower-court…

  21. KCEN Waco

    Supreme Court weighs whether to let Trump's birthright citizenship restrictions take effect (opens KCEN Waco)

    Published

    KCEN Waco's feed description

    In Thursday's arguments, the justices will be weighing whether judges have the authority to issue what are called nationwide, or universal, injunctions.

  22. New York Post

    Supreme Court agonizes over whether lower courts can block Trump birthright citizenship order (opens New York Post)

    Published

    New York Post's feed description

    Supreme Court justices agonized over the ground rules they should set up for lower courts during oral arguments Thursday in the Trump administration's bid to end a nationwide block on the president's executive order on birthright citizenship.

  23. Newsweek

    Good and bad signs for Trump at birthright citizenship hearing (opens Newsweek)

    Published

    Newsweek's feed description

    Justices grilled the government on how changes would be enforced, while also raising concerns around lower court injunctions.

  24. The Boston Globe

    Supreme Court weighed arguments in case over Trump’s birthright citizenship order (opens The Boston Globe)

    Published

    The Boston Globe's feed description

    President Trump signed an executive order that would deny citizenship to children who are born to people who are in the country illegally or temporarily.

  25. The Guardian

    Supreme court to hear birthright citizenship dispute – US politics live (opens The Guardian)

    Published

    The Guardian's feed description

    Case could create different citizenship rules in different states while legal challenges continue

Showing the first 25 of 88 headlines. ·

Identical headlines usually mean shared wire copy. They are counted as separate articles but are not independent confirmation.

Supreme Court justices seem divided in birthright citizenship arguments | Since Then