Coverage dated May 22, 2024

Supreme Court sides with South Carolina Republicans in redistricting dispute

Headline from CBS News

The Supreme Court reversed a decision from lower court that found GOP lawmakers improperly used race when designing one of South Carolina's congressional districts.

CBS News's own description from its feed. We collect headlines and these descriptions, not full articles; read the original reporting below.

Reports & sources

31 articles, oldest first.

  1. CBS News

    Supreme Court sides with South Carolina Republicans in redistricting dispute (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    The Supreme Court reversed a decision from lower court that found GOP lawmakers improperly used race when designing one of South Carolina's congressional districts.

  2. The Washington Free Beacon

    Supreme Court Rules Against Challenge to South Carolina Voting Map (opens The Washington Free Beacon)

    Published

    The Washington Free Beacon's feed description

    The Supreme Court on Thursday handed a victory to South Carolina Republicans, ruling against a challenge to an electoral map they devised that moved 30,000 black residents out of a congressional district.

  3. Roll Call

    Supreme Court backs South Carolina's congressional map (opens Roll Call)

    Published

    Roll Call's feed description

    A divided Supreme Court on Thursday overturned a lower court ruling that found South Carolina had discriminated against Black voters.

  4. NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth

    Supreme Court rules South Carolina congressional map was not racially gerrymandered (opens NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth)

    Published

    NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth's feed description

    The high court's conservative majority preserved a Republican-held South Carolina congressional district, rejecting a lower-court ruling that said the district...

  5. Courthouse News Service

    Supreme Court sides with Republicans over South Carolina voting maps (opens Courthouse News Service)

    Published

    Courthouse News Service's feed description

    The justices rejected critics who said the Republican-dominated legislature's maps were drawn to drown out the political voice of Black voters, who tend to vote for Democrats.

  6. The Daily Signal

    Supreme Court Says South Carolina Did Not Racially Gerrymander (opens The Daily Signal)

    Published

    The Daily Signal's feed description

    The Supreme Court rules 6-3 in favor of South Carolina, says a lower court "clearly erred" in gerrymander case.

  7. SCOTUSblog

    Court rules for South Carolina Republicans in dispute over congressional map (opens SCOTUSblog)

    Published

    SCOTUSblog's feed description

    The Supreme Court on Thursday threw out a ruling by a federal district court holding that a congressional district on the South Carolina coast was an unconstitutional racial gerrymander – that is, it sorted voters based primarily on their race. In an opinion by Justice Samuel Alito, the justices cle

  8. Los Angeles Times

    Supreme Court OKs shift of Black voters to shore up GOP congressional district (opens Los Angeles Times)

    Published

    Los Angeles Times's feed description

    Justices uphold a redistricting map drawn by South Carolina's Republican Legislature and overturn a lower court ruling that called it a 'stark racial gerrymander.'

  9. Rolling Stone

    Supreme Court Does South Carolina GOP a Solid, Overturns Racial Gerrymander Ruling (opens Rolling Stone)

    Published

    Rolling Stone's feed description

    The Supreme Court overturned a lower court ruling that determined South Carolina unlawfully removed 30,000 Black voters from the state’s 1st District.

  10. Fox News

    Supreme Court upholds GOP-drawn voting map in South Carolina gerrymandering case (opens Fox News)

    Published

    Fox News's feed description

    The Supreme Court on Thursday ruled to reverse a lower court's decision that said a South Carolina redistricting map was unconstitutional.

  11. Christian Science Monitor

    Split Supreme Court sides with GOP in South Carolina redistricting case (opens Christian Science Monitor)

    Published

    Christian Science Monitor's feed description

    Despite Supreme Court rulings that created a new majority Black district in Louisiana and Alabama, the court kept a coastal South Carolina district mostly white – and Republican.

  12. RedState

  13. Washington Examiner

    Supreme Court backs GOP-drawn South Carolina congressional map (opens Washington Examiner)

    Published

    Washington Examiner's feed description

    The Supreme Court found a South Carolina congressional map accused of racial gerrymandering can stand, reversing a district court decision that struck down the lines.

  14. The Guardian

    Supreme court rules South Carolina doesn’t need to redraw congressional map to consider Black voters (opens The Guardian)

    Published

    The Guardian's feed description

    Justices send case back to lower court, saying it didn’t properly evaluate evidence in ruling Republican plan was discriminatory

  15. Legal Insurrection

    Supreme Court Upholds South Carolina Voting Map as Constitutional (opens Legal Insurrection)

    Published

    Legal Insurrection's feed description

    Alito: "They [the challengers] provided no direct evidence of a racial gerrymander, and their circumstantial evidence is very weak."

  16. New York Post

    Supreme Court upholds South Carolina congressional map in win for GOP, finding no bias against black voters (opens New York Post)

    Published

    New York Post's feed description

    The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld South Carolina's congressional map after determining that partisan aspirations rather than racial motives colored the line-drawing process.

  17. NBC News

    Supreme Court rules for GOP in South Carolina redistricting case (opens NBC News)

    Published

    NBC News's feed description

    The Supreme Court ruled that Republicans in South Carolina did not unlawfully consider race when they drew a congressional district in a way that removed thousands of Black voters.

  18. Local News 8

    Supreme Court approves South Carolina congressional map previously found to dilute Black voting power (opens Local News 8)

    Published

    Local News 8's feed description

    By John Fritze, Tierney Sneed and Devan Cole, CNN (CNN) — The Supreme Court upheld a pro-Republican South Carolina congressional map Thursday, rejecting the argument raised by civil rights groups that lawmakers impermissibly used race as a proxy to bolster the GOP’s chances.

  19. NPR

    Supreme Court rules in South Carolina gerrymandering case (opens NPR)

    Published

    NPR's feed description

    The U.S. Supreme Court, in a 6-3 vote along ideological lines, reversed a lower court decision that had struck down a South Carolina congressional district as a racial gerrymander.

  20. New York Times

    Supreme Court Sides With Republicans Over South Carolina Voting Map (opens New York Times)

    Published

    New York Times's feed description

    The case concerned a constitutional puzzle: how to distinguish the roles of race and partisanship in drawing voting maps when Black voters overwhelmingly favor Democrats.

  21. Truthout

    Conservative Supreme Court Justices Give “Okay” to Racial Gerrymander In South Carolina (opens Truthout)

    Published

    Truthout's feed description

    Pundits noted the "disastrous" decision "gives politicians the greenlight to racially gerrymander" elsewhere in the US.

  22. The Daily Caller

    Supreme Court Rules South Carolina Did Not Racially Gerrymander Congressional District Map (opens The Daily Caller)

    Published

    The Daily Caller's feed description

    The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 Thursday that a lower court “clearly erred” when it held that South Carolina racially gerrymandered its congressional district map.

  23. Voice of America

    US Supreme Court backs South Carolina Republicans in race-based voting map fight (opens Voice of America)

    Published

    Voice of America's feed description

    Justices rule against challenge to Republican-devised map that moved 30,000 Black residents out of a congressional district

  24. Anchorage Daily News

    Supreme Court allows disputed South Carolina voting map that critics say excludes Black voters (opens Anchorage Daily News)

    Published

    Anchorage Daily News's feed description

    State lawmakers who approved the map said the changes were driven by political party, not race.

  25. Forbes

    Supreme Court Upholds South Carolina House Map Accused Of Diluting Black Residents’ Votes (opens Forbes)

    Published

    Forbes's feed description

    The allegedly discriminatory map was already set to be used in the November election, after the court dragged its feet in ruling on the case.

Identical headlines usually mean shared wire copy. They are counted as separate articles but are not independent confirmation.

Supreme Court sides with South Carolina Republicans in redistricting dispute | Since Then