Coverage dated August 16, 2023

Maui emergency management director defends decision not to sound sirens in fire

Headline from NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth

West Maui’s sirens are used primarily for tsunamis, MEMA Administrator Herman Andaya said as questions about warnings before the deadly wildfire are raised.

NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth's own description from its feed. We collect headlines and these descriptions, not full articles; read the original reporting below.

Earlier updates in this story

Read the reports

Reports & sources

19 articles, oldest first.

  1. NBC News

    Maui officials defend decision not to sound sirens during wildfire (opens NBC News)

    Published

    NBC News's feed description

    West Maui’s sirens are used primarily for tsunamis, MEMA Administrator Herman Andaya said as questions about warnings before the deadly wildfire are raised.

  2. Deutsche Welle

    Hawaii defends lack of siren warnings during wildfire – DW (opens Deutsche Welle)

    Published

    Deutsche Welle's feed description

    Activating Hawaii's emergency sirens, primarily used to issue tsunami warnings, could have sent people on Maui from the coast to the burning forests, the head of Maui’s Emergency Management Agency said.

  3. NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth

    Maui emergency management director defends decision not to sound sirens in fire (opens NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth)

    Published

    NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth's feed description

    West Maui’s sirens are used primarily for tsunamis, MEMA Administrator Herman Andaya said as questions about warnings before the deadly wildfire are raised.

  4. CNN

    Maui's warning sirens stayed silent as wildfires approached Lahaina. Here's what we know (opens CNN)

    Published

    CNN's feed description

    Authorities face mounting questions about whether more could have been done to warn residents as wildfires devastated western Maui earlier this month, after Hawaii’s siren warning system stayed silent while wildfires reduced the town of Lahaina to ashes.

  5. NBC News

    California town that lost 85 to wildfire installs sirens. Maui officials failed to use theirs. (opens NBC News)

    Published

    NBC News's feed description

    The new alarms are being installed in Paradise as officials in Hawaii defend the decision not to sound warning sirens in a wildfire that recently swept into the town of Lahaina.

  6. NBC News

    ‘A last resort’: Maui’s emergency management director repeatedly downplayed sirens, records show (opens NBC News)

    Published

    NBC News's feed description

    Since the wildfires that killed more than 100 people earlier this month, some survivors have said that some of the victims could have made it out had the sirens sounded.

  7. The Hill

    Maui official explains why sirens weren’t activated during wildfire evacuations (opens The Hill)

    Published

    The Hill's feed description

    Officials in Maui are defending their decision not to activate the county’s emergency sirens during the wildfires that tore through parts of the island last week.

  8. Governing

    Maui Stands by Decision to Keep Emergency Sirens Silent (opens Governing)

    Published

    Governing's feed description

    The island’s Emergency Management Agency reported that the sirens are for tsunamis and are not a part of the agency’s standard wildfire response protocol. Instead, a variety of emergency notifications were used to alert residents of the danger.

  9. Los Angeles Times

    Sirens were silent during the Lahaina fire. Maui's emergency chief says he doesn't regret it (opens Los Angeles Times)

    Published

    Los Angeles Times's feed description

    Herman Andaya, who leads Maui’s Emergency Management Agency, defended the decision not to sound warning sirens amid the catastrophic Lahaina fire.

  10. Forbes

    Maui Officials Say Warning Sirens Would Not Have Saved Lives As Fire Death Toll Climbs To 111 (opens Forbes)

    Published

    Forbes's feed description

    Hawaii’s extensive emergency siren warning system stayed silent during the deadly wildfires.

  11. ABC 7 Los Angeles

    Maui's warning sirens stayed silent as wildfires approached Lahaina; EMA official defends decision (opens ABC 7 Los Angeles)

    Published

    ABC 7 Los Angeles's feed description

    Authorities face mounting questions about whether more could have been done to warn residents as wildfires devastated western Maui.

  12. CBS News

    Maui official defends his decision not to activate sirens amid wildfires: "I do not" regret it (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    Maui Emergency Management Agency Administrator Herman Andaya has made his first public comments since the deadly wildfires ignited last week.

  13. KHON 2 Honolulu

    County defends decision to not activate sirens during Maui fires (opens KHON 2 Honolulu)

    Published

    KHON 2 Honolulu's feed description

    HONOLULU (KHON2) — The use of emergency sirens during wildfires is mentioned on county and state emergency websites. But Maui County officials are defending their decision on not using them w…

  14. New York Post

    Maui chief doesn’t regret not activating sirens during wildfire: ‘We would not have saved those people’ (opens New York Post)

    Published

    New York Post's feed description

    “Had we sounded the siren that night, we’re afraid that people would have gotten mauka … they would have gone into the fire.”

Identical headlines usually mean shared wire copy. They are counted as separate articles but are not independent confirmation.

Maui emergency management director defends decision not to sound sirens in fire | Since Then