Coverage dated August 24, 2026 to August 26, 2026

Legal breakdown of testimony about religion in Lindsay Clancy trial

Headline from CBS News

Closing arguments are expected this week in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial for the killings of her three young children. Attorney and legal analyst Joe Tamburino joins CBS News to discuss the case and a moment on Monday where witness testimony was cut short over comments about religion.

CBS News's own description from its feed. We collect headlines and these descriptions, not full articles; read the original reporting below.

Earlier updates in this story

Read the reports

Reports & sources

17 articles, oldest first.

  1. News Nation Now

    Lindsay Clancy defense seeks mistrial after ‘mortal sin’ raised again (opens News Nation Now)

    Published

    News Nation Now's feed description

    The judge denied the mistrial motion but struck what he called “absolutely inappropriate” religious testimony.

  2. CBS News

    Judge in Lindsay Clancy case rejects defense's call for mistrial (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    The judge presiding over the Lindsay Clancy murder case rejected the defense's push for a mistrial on Monday. Clancy has admitted to killing her children but has pleaded not guilty, arguing that postpartum psychosis caused her actions.

  3. Court TV

    Lindsay Clancy’s attorney accuses prosecutors of ‘intentional misconduct’ after 2nd reference to ‘mortal sin’ (opens Court TV)

    Published

    Court TV's feed description

    PLYMOUTH, Mass. (Court TV) — Lindsay Clancy‘s defense attorney asked the judge to declare a mistrial in her case after a second reference to “mortal sin” during the murder trial. Clancy, 36, is charged with murder in the deaths of her three children — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8.

  4. WHDH Boston

    Judge in Lindsay Clancy murder trial denies defense request for mistrial (opens WHDH Boston)

    Published

    WHDH Boston's feed description

    The judge presiding over Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial denied her defense team’s request for a mistrial Monday afternoon, after Clancy’s attorney called out testimony from...

  5. NBC News

    Judge in Lindsay Clancy case denies defense's motion for mistrial after witness brings up religion (opens NBC News)

    Published

    NBC News's feed description

    Lindsay Clancy's trial defense team requested a mistrial after a prosecution witness brought up Clancy's Catholic faith. The judge denied the motion, but instructed jurors to dismiss the comments and sent them home early. NBC Boston's Sue O'Connell reports.

  6. CBS News

    Lindsay Clancy trial judge tells jurors to disregard religious testimony (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    Defense attorneys for Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother who admitted to killing her children, called for a mistrial on Monday, citing a witness who used the phrase "moral sin." The judge denied the request. CBS News correspondent Shanelle Kaul reports.

  7. CBS News

    Latest on Lindsay Clancy trial as judge denies mistrial request (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    Lindsay Clancy's defense team asked for a mistrial Monday after a witness began speaking about Catholic religion. The judge in the case denied the request. CBS News' Shanelle Kaul has more.

  8. CBS News

    Lindsay Clancy defense calls for mistrial after witness brings up Clancy's Catholic faith (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    Closing arguments are expected this week in the murder case of Lindsay Clancy. The defense called for a mistrial on Monday after a prosecution witness brought up Clancy's Catholic faith and the concept of mortal sin. Shanelle Kaul has more details from the courthouse.

  9. Revolver News

  10. NBC Boston

    Lindsay Clancy trial resumes today after mistrial request denied (opens NBC Boston)

    Published

    NBC Boston's feed description

    Attorney Kevin Reddington and defendant Lindsay Clancy wait for a ruling from Judge William Sullivan after Reddington asked for a mistrial in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday, Aug. 24, 2026.

  11. News Nation Now

    Lindsay Clancy jurors return to court after judge denies mistrial (opens News Nation Now)

    Published

    News Nation Now's feed description

    Judge William Sullivan denied a defense mistrial request after “mortal sin” surfaced for a second time at trial.

  12. CBS News

    Why the judge in the Lindsay Clancy trial scolded prosecutors for testimony on her faith (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    The defense in the Lindsay Clancy trial called for a mistrial after a witness brought up Lindsay Clancy's Catholic faith. The judge did not declare a mistrial, but he reprimanded prosecutors and told the jury to ignore that testimony. Trial lawyer Mark Eiglarsh explains more.

  13. Washington Examiner

    Judge in Lindsay Clancy trial denies mistrial motion after witness testifies about Catholicism (opens Washington Examiner)

    Published

    Washington Examiner's feed description

    The judge in the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy declined the defense’s motion for a mistrial over a witness’s testimony about Catholicism but reprimanded the prosecution over the matter. Dr. Kirk Heilbrun, a forensic psychologist who has testified as to the competency of defendants to stand trial in…

  14. CBS News

    Lindsay Clancy's prosecutors question final witnesses about her mental health (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    Lindsay Clancy's defense team asked for a mistrial after a prosecution witness brought up Clancy's religious beliefs. The judge denied the request but reprimanded prosecutors. CBS News legal contributor Caroline Polisi has the latest analysis.

  15. CBS News

    Expert explains why Lindsay Clancy's religious beliefs have no legal weight (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    The judge in the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy denied a mistrial request from her attorneys but scolded the prosecution after a witness brought up Clancy's religious beliefs. CBS News' Shanelle Kaul reports, and legal analyst Joe Tamburino weighs in.

  16. CBS News

    Legal breakdown of testimony about religion in Lindsay Clancy trial (opens CBS News)

    Published

    CBS News's feed description

    Closing arguments are expected this week in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial for the killings of her three young children. Attorney and legal analyst Joe Tamburino joins CBS News to discuss the case and a moment on Monday where witness testimony was cut short over comments about religion.

  17. Charisma Magazine Online

    Judge Shuts Down Lindsay Clancy’s Legal Team’s Push for a Mistrial After Faith Comes Into Play (opens Charisma Magazine Online)

    Published

    Charisma Magazine Online's feed description

    As the trial of Lindsay Clancy appears to be winding down, the alleged murderer’s defense team’s latest legal gambit appears to have come up rather short. According to multiple reports, the judge presiding over this case of great national curiosity denied that gambit, effectively ending the mistrial…