Coverage dated February 2, 2023 to February 8, 2023

China Has Conducted a Spy Balloon Program for Years, Pentagon Says

Headline from NBC Los Angeles, on the newest of 3 developments

The Pentagon says the Chinese balloon shot down off the South Carolina coast was part of a large surveillance program that China has been conducting for “several years.”

NBC Los Angeles's own description from its feed. We collect headlines and these descriptions, not full articles; read the original reporting below.

Earlier updates in this story

Developments in this update

3 dated developments, oldest first, newest marked. Each is named by one outlet's own headline; open its reports to see every outlet that covered it.

  1. Pentagon Admits It Failed To Spot 3 Chinese Spy Balloons During Trump’s Term

    Headline from Forbes ·

  2. China's spy balloon was 200 ft tall, carried payload the size of a jet

    Headline from Newsweek ·

  3. Newest

    China Has Conducted a Spy Balloon Program for Years, Pentagon Says

    Headline from NBC Los Angeles ·

4 reports not tied to one development ·

Read the reports

Reports & sources

53 articles, oldest first.

  1. Deutsche Welle

    China 'spy balloon:' Why doesn't the Pentagon shoot it down? – DW (opens Deutsche Welle)

    Published

    Deutsche Welle's feed description

    Espionage is all about secrets — keeping and revealing them. But here's what we can say about the alleged spy balloon.

  2. The Daily Caller

    Pentagon Reveals Why It Waited Days To Shoot Down Chinese Surveillance Balloon (opens The Daily Caller)

    Published

    The Daily Caller's feed description

    The U.S. was able to collect valuable information on China's surveillance capabilities while observing the spy balloon as it traversed the U.S.

  3. Insider

    After a week adrift, a surveillance balloon from China has been deflated. Here's what we know about the suspect device and its mission. (opens Insider)

    Published

    Insider's feed description

    The balloon, which Pentagon officials said was a surveillance device but China claims was a civilian meteorological aircraft, was shot down Saturday.

  4. Forbes

    Pentagon Admits It Failed To Spot 3 Chinese Spy Balloons During Trump’s Term (opens Forbes)

    Published

    Forbes's feed description

    The military shot down a suspected Chinese surveillance balloon over the weekend.

  5. The Diplomat

    China Admits There’s a 2nd Chinese Balloon Over Latin America (opens The Diplomat)

    Published

    The Diplomat's feed description

    Like the balloon spotted over the United States, the Pentagon claimed the object was used for surveillance; Beijing says it was blown off course while conducting civilian research.

  6. Richmond Times-Dispatch

    Source: Chinese spy balloon previously spotted near Norfolk, elsewhere (opens Richmond Times-Dispatch)

    Published

    Richmond Times-Dispatch's feed description

    Alleged Chinese spy balloons were spotted on several occasions during President Donald Trump’s administration, including three instances where they traveled near sensitive U.S. military facilities and training areas, according to

  7. ABC 17 Mid-Missouri

    Exclusive: US intel assessment documents Chinese spy balloon incident under Trump (opens ABC 17 Mid-Missouri)

    Published

    ABC 17 Mid-Missouri's feed description

    By Zachary Cohen, CNN A US military intelligence report from last year that focused on China’s use of high-altitude balloons mentioned sightings in Hawaii and Florida during the Trump presidency, according to an excerpt of the report reviewed by CNN.

  8. Legitgov

  9. Newsweek

    China's spy balloon was 200 ft tall, carried payload the size of a jet (opens Newsweek)

    Published

    Newsweek's feed description

    As the recovery effort continued Tuesday, China's foreign ministry said the balloon "doesn't belong to the U.S."

  10. The Daily Signal

    Did China Send Spy Balloons During Trump Presidency? FAA Not Saying (opens The Daily Signal)

    Published

    The Daily Signal's feed description

    Former Trump administration officials, now Trump critics, say they’re unaware of any China spy balloons over America during his presidency.

  11. Newsweek

    Secret Chinese spy balloon under Donald Trump passed through these states (opens Newsweek)

    Published

    Newsweek's feed description

    Officials said Chinese balloons travelled into U.S. airspace on at least three occasions during the Trump presidency and once previously during Biden's tenure.

  12. The Guardian

    Chinese spy balloon seen above Hawaii and Florida in 2019, report says (opens The Guardian)

    Published

    The Guardian's feed description

    Air force report details balloon while Pentagon officials say China had sent three over the US during Trump’s time in office

  13. The Brunswick News

    Chinese balloons were spotted near US bases during Trump’s era (opens The Brunswick News)

    Published

    The Brunswick News's feed description

    WASHINGTON — Alleged Chinese spy balloons were spotted on several occasions during President Donald Trump’s administration, including three instances where they traveled near sensitive U.S. military facilities and training areas,

  14. Washington Examiner

    Spy balloon only a piece of China’s 'brazen' actions inside the US (opens Washington Examiner)

    Published

    Washington Examiner's feed description

    The Chinese spy balloon that floated across the continental United States last week is only one piece of Beijing’s “brazen” actions inside the U.S., as China seeks to buy up U.S. farmland and targets Chinese dissidents inside America’s borders.

  15. The New Republic

    Report: Chinese Balloon Flew Directly Over Florida During the Trump Administration (opens The New Republic)

    Published

    The New Republic's feed description

    Even Fox News is admitting that there have been Chinese balloons before.

  16. France 24

    US recovering 'spy' balloon debris for analysis, no plans to return it to China (opens France 24)

    Published

    France 24's feed description

    The United States is recovering debris from the downed Chinese balloon in the Atlantic for analysis by intelligence experts and there is no plan to give the remains back to Beijing, officials said Monday.

  17. Washington Examiner

    What the US military did well (and badly) with China's balloon (opens Washington Examiner)

    Published

    Washington Examiner's feed description

    The U.S. military's record on dealing with China's spy balloon challenge? It's a mixed bag.

  18. Insider

    China is mad at the US for blasting its suspected spy balloon, but a few years ago, state TV bragged its fighter pilots could shoot one down (opens Insider)

    Published

    Insider's feed description

    Video from China state TV shows a 2020 training exercise involving Chinese fighter pilots shooting down a surveillance balloon.

  19. Deutsche Welle

    China claims downed balloon as US recovers debris – DW (opens Deutsche Welle)

    Published

    Deutsche Welle's feed description

    The US and China exchanged words about a suspected Chinese spy balloon as military officials revealed other incursions. US officials said the downed craft was massive in size.

  20. The Washington Free Beacon

    China Threatens To Retaliate Over Downed Spy Balloon (opens The Washington Free Beacon)

    Published

    The Washington Free Beacon's feed description

    China on Sunday threatened to retaliate against the United States after the Biden administration waited at least four days to shoot down a Chinese spy balloon that floated near several military and nuclear sites.

  21. BizPac Review

    Defense officials say Chinese spy balloons flew in Trump's term, one over Florida (opens BizPac Review)

    Published

    BizPac Review's feed description

    A host of possible Chinese surveillance balloons have been identified throughout the globe in recent years, including up to eight in the U.S. since former President Donald […]

  22. The Diplomat

    What the Chinese Surveillance Balloon Incident Tells Us About US-China Relations (opens The Diplomat)

    Published

    The Diplomat's feed description

    A U.S. F-22 shot down a Chinese surveillance balloon that lingered in U.S. territorial airspace for days. What now?

  23. The Daily Caller

    Here Are All The Chinese Spy Balloons Detected Since The Trump Administration (opens The Daily Caller)

    Published

    The Daily Caller's feed description

    The Chinese balloon the U.S. military shot down Saturday generated widespread attention, but number of possible Chinese surveillance balloons have been spotted.

  24. PoliticusUSA

    Trump Spy Balloons Only Found Because Biden Ordered Increased Vigilance (opens PoliticusUSA)

    Published

    PoliticusUSA's feed description

    The only reason we know about those Trump Chinese spy balloons is because President Biden ordered the intelligence community “to increase both our vigilance and the assets that we were deploying to be able to detect Chinese efforts to spy against the United States.”

  25. Insider

    The 3 Chinese spy balloons spotted during the Trump administration were initially classified as UFOs (opens Insider)

    Published

    Insider's feed description

    Pentagon officials acknowledged they failed to detect the balloons during the Trump administration due to a "domain awareness gap."

Showing the first 25 of 30 headlines. ·

Identical headlines usually mean shared wire copy. They are counted as separate articles but are not independent confirmation.