Gone quiet · last update Oct 16, 2025 / Alabama

The fight over IVF after Alabama's ruling that frozen embryos are children

Overview · reviewed October 28, 2026

In February 2024 the Alabama Supreme Court ruled that frozen embryos created through in vitro fertilization can be considered children under the state's wrongful death law, and several of the state's IVF providers halted treatments.[1][2] The ruling set off a national fight over IVF in an election year: Alabama quickly passed a law shielding providers, Senate Democrats pushed bills to guarantee access, and Donald Trump called himself the "father of IVF."[3][4][5] As president, Trump signed an in February 2025 meant to expand access and lower costs.[6]

Read the timeline

Follow this story to see new developments when you return.

The ruling set off a national fight over IVF in an election year: Alabama quickly passed a law shielding providers, Senate Democrats pushed bills to guarantee access, and Donald Trump called himself the "father of IVF."[3][4][5] As president, Trump signed an in February 2025 meant to expand access and lower costs.[6]

Coverage over time

Share of tracked outlets · monthly average of weekly shares (UTC)

Feb 2024: average weekly share 38% (left 14%, center 15%, right 10%), from 2 of 2 weeksMar 2024: average weekly share 9% (left 4%, center 3%, right 2%), from 4 of 4 weeksApr 2024: average weekly share 1% (left under 1%, center under 1%, right under 1%), from 5 of 5 weeksMay 2024: average weekly share 1% (left under 1%, center under 1%, right under 1%), from 4 of 4 weeksJun 2024: average weekly share 4% (left 2%, center 1%, right 1%), from 4 of 4 weeksJul 2024: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksAug 2024: average weekly share 6% (left 1%, center 2%, right 2%), from 4 of 4 weeksSep 2024: average weekly share 3% (left 1%, center 2%, right under 1%), from 5 of 5 weeksOct 2024: average weekly share 2% (left 1%, center under 1%, right 1%), from 4 of 4 weeksNov 2024: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksDec 2024: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksJan 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksFeb 2025: average weekly share 3% (left 1%, center 1%, right 1%), from 4 of 4 weeksMar 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksApr 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksMay 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksJun 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksJul 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksAug 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksSep 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksOct 2025: average weekly share 2% (left 1%, center 1%, right 1%), from 4 of 4 weeksNov 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksDec 2025: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksJan 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksFeb 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksMar 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksApr 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksMay 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksJun 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksJul 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksAug 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 5 of 5 weeksSep 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksOct 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 4 of 4 weeksNov 2026: average weekly share 0% (left 0%, center 0%, right 0%), from 2 of 2 weeks, so far

LeftCenterRight

Each bar is the share of the outlets on our Left / Center / Right rating scale that we tracked publishing that week which carried reporting on this story, split by the outlets' ratings. Over more than two years each bar is a month: the average of that month's weekly shares, so the shape stays readable. The weekly table below keeps every week. We track more outlets now than in the archive, so a share keeps earlier and later weeks comparable. An outlet counts once a week however much it published, and outlets in one ownership or syndication group count as one on each side they appear on. A rating describes the outlet, not the report. A gap means no such reports were collected that week, not that nothing was reported anywhere. Weeks run Monday to Sunday in UTC, so a report published on a Sunday evening in US Eastern time counts in the next week. 7 more outlets off the scale (not rated, or outside the left-right graphs) also reported; they are not in this chart. See them.

Weekly counts, outlets and reports (13 weeks with coverage)
Outlets on the rating scale that carried this story each week, of the outlets tracked that week, newest first
Week of (UTC)LeftCenterRightOf trackedShareReceipts
Oct 13, 202547617 of 1829%
Feb 17, 2025710926 of 19413%
Oct 14, 202473414 of 1957%
Sep 16, 2024920534 of 20916%
Aug 26, 2024918936 of 20418%
Aug 19, 2024121114 of 2097%
Jun 10, 20241514635 of 24714%
May 20, 20241135 of 2262%
Apr 1, 20242619 of 2643%
Mar 25, 202499523 of 2459%
Mar 4, 202428261569 of 25427%
Feb 26, 202425341776 of 25630%
Feb 19, 2024404029109 of 23247%

Latest coverage

The newest reporting in this story's record.

  1. Oct 15, 2025 · first reported · Headline from WDIO Duluth

    Trump announces a deal with a manufacturer to make a common fertility drug cheaper for IVF patients

Background

The Alabama Supreme Court's first-of-its-kind ruling held that people who destroy frozen embryos can be held liable for wrongful death,[7] and the court's chief justice drew on religious reasoning.[8] Clinics in the state stopped IVF treatments,[2] patients scrambled,[9] and leaders in both parties rushed to respond.[10] Some Republicans joined Democrats in expressing alarm,[11] Nikki Haley said embryos were "babies,"[12] and Trump said he supported access to IVF.[13] A Florida bill allowing wrongful death suits over a fetus was shelved.[14]

Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey signed a law in March granting legal protections to IVF providers,[3] though one health system later said it would stop offering IVF.[15] That month a Democrat who made reproductive rights central to her campaign won a for an Alabama legislative seat.[16] In Washington, Senate Democrats brought IVF access bills to votes in June and September,[4][17] and two Republican senators proposed a bill to stop states from banning IVF.[18] The Southern Baptist Convention voted to oppose IVF,[19] Trump promised to make IVF free for women if elected,[20] and in February 2025 he signed an order to expand access and reduce costs.[6]

Supporting stories (20)
  1. Alabama Supreme Court rules frozen embryos are 'children' under state law
  2. Gov. Abbott says he supports IVF, stops short of calling for law to protect access in Texas
  3. Alabama governor signs legislation protecting IVF providers from legal liability into law
  4. 'Right to IVF Act' blocked by Senate Republicans in latest battle
  5. Trump declares himself 'father of IVF' at Fox News town hall with all-female audience
  6. Trump signs order to study how to expand IVF and calls for ‘radical transparency' from government
  7. Ruling pauses IVF cases in Alabama
  8. Bible-quoting Alabama chief justice sparks church-state debate in embryo ruling
  9. Alabama lawmakers look for IVF solution as patients remain in limbo - The Daily Reporter
  10. Alabama lawmakers are planning legislation to 'protect' IVF | Here's the latest
  11. Some Republicans are voicing doubt over Alabama IVF ruling. Democrats see an opportunity
  12. Haley sides with Alabama Supreme Court on IVF ruling: ‘Embryos, to me, are babies’
  13. Trump expresses support for IVF as he calls on Alabama to find solution to issue that has GOP scrambling
  14. Florida lawmaker pulls bill on wrongful death of unborn children after Alabama IVF ruling
  15. Alabama hospital to end IVF treatments at the end of the year, citing litigation concerns
  16. Democrat wins Alabama special election after focusing on IVF, abortion
  17. Senate to vote again on IVF protections in election-year push
  18. Republicans Ted Cruz and Katie Britt introduce bill to protect IVF access
  19. Southern Baptists pass resolution formally opposing IVF
  20. Trump calls for universal coverage of IVF treatment with no specifics on how his plan would work

The full record

Each date is when an update was first reported.

All 32 recorded updates

October 2025

  1. Trump announces plan to lower the cost of a common IVF drugHeadline from NBC News · 18 outlets

October 2024

  1. Trump declares himself 'father of IVF' at Fox News town hall with all-female audienceHeadline from ABC 7 Los Angeles · 14 outlets

September 2024

  1. Senate to vote again on IVF protections in election-year pushHeadline from ABC 13 Houston · 12 outlets
  2. Senate GOP blocks IVF bill again as Democrats spotlight issue ahead of electionsHeadline from ABC 30 Fresno · 26 outlets

June 2024

  1. 'Right to IVF Act' blocked by Senate Republicans in latest battleHeadline from FOX 4 Dallas · 27 outlets
  2. Southern Baptists pass resolution formally opposing IVFHeadline from NBC 6 South Florida · 19 outlets

May 2024

  1. Republicans Ted Cruz and Katie Britt introduce bill to protect IVF accessHeadline from CBS News · 5 outlets

February 2024

  1. Alabama governor signs legislation protecting IVF providers from legal liability into lawHeadline from KREM Spokane · 63 outlets
  2. Florida lawmaker pulls bill on wrongful death of unborn children after Alabama IVF rulingHeadline from NBC 6 South Florida · 7 outlets
  3. Republicans block Senate bill to protect nationwide access to IVF treatmentsHeadline from KOB 4 · 40 outlets
  4. Alabama lawmakers look for IVF solution as patients remain in limbo - The Daily ReporterHeadline from Green Field Reporter · 8 outlets
  5. Gov. Abbott says he supports IVF, stops short of calling for law to protect access in TexasHeadline from ABC 17 Mid-Missouri · 8 outlets
  6. Alabama IVF ruling puts spotlight on state plans for tax breaks and child support for fetusesHeadline from Bangor Daily News · 14 outlets
  7. Alabama lawmakers advance plan to protect IVF clinicsHeadline from Kokomo Tribune · 37 outlets
  8. Trump expresses support for IVF as he calls on Alabama to find solution to issue that has GOP scramblingHeadline from KVIA El Paso · 35 outlets
  9. Some Republicans are voicing doubt over Alabama IVF ruling. Democrats see an opportunityHeadline from The Republic · 24 outlets

Coverage & sources

Read the reports, see how much was collected over time, or compare outlets by political leaning.

Coverage & sources →